Must you engage in PMS as well as in mutual funds?

Portfolio Management Service (PMS) may be obtained from various sources, including independent portfolio managers, brokerage houses, and AMCs. Asset Management Companies' mutual fund schemes are well-known and widely used (AMCs). PMS is tailored investments, like mutual funds, that consider an investor's risk tolerance. Here, we'll compare and contrast PMs and mutual funds.

Mutual funds and other forms of portfolio management are often seen as interchangeable. Nonetheless, the two are vastly different from one another. Mutual funds cater to a wider audience yet provide less personalized options.PMS caters to a certain demographic of investors and allows for more personalization. Here, we compare PMS and MFs to see how they vary and to learn about their potential benefits and drawbacks.

Premenstrual Syndrome and Its Variations

Portfolio Management Service (PMS) is an investment service provided by a portfolio manager in which clients can construct investment portfolios according to their individual risk tolerances, time horizons, and other criteria. When one purchases PMS, one acquires legal title to bonds or shares in the company. Yet, in mutual funds, only the fund units may be owned by investors.

  • Access Fees with loading

Most PMS providers will charge an entrance load fee whenever an investor joins a program. It's possible to see a 1% to 3% spread.

  • Maintenance Costs:

Costs associated with maintaining the portfolio are referred to as "operating expenses" and are incurred regularly. SEBI has imposed a ceiling of 0.5% per year on the average daily assets managed for each customer.

  • Brokerage Fees:

PMS vendors impose a commission on all trades.

  • Exit Load Fees

When an investor cashes out their holdings, they are subject to an exit load charge.

If an investor cashes out within the first year, the exit burden can be at most 3%, per new SEBI regulations. The fees for leaving in the second year are 2% and the third year is 1%. All exit load fees are waived at the end of the third year.

Mutual Funds

Mutual funds buy bonds, stocks, and other assets. AMCs invest investor funds in various securities. Diversified portfolios reduce risk. Each mutual fund scheme has a fund manager who analyzes and invests pooled resources. Examples include stocks, gold, bonds, commercial documents, and government notes.

Asset class-based mutual funds:

  • Equity funds
  • Debt funds
  • Hybrid funding

Which one should you choose? PMS vs. Mutual Funds

This will be determined by your investment capital, your comfort level with taking risks, and your monetary objectives. Mutual funds are an alternative when you have a modest corpus and want to avoid being subject to significant tax compliance requirements.

On the other hand, if your corpus consists of 6 or 7 digits and calls for personalization in addition to other features, PMS can be your best option. Here are some of the things to know before an investment.

  • Asset allocation

PMS must have a minimum portfolio size of Rs.50 lakh to comply with SEBI regulations (minimum). Some fund managers, however, routinely impose stricter limits. Nonetheless, a person may begin investing in mutual funds with as little as Rs.500.Flexibility

  • Mutual funds adhere to a strict structure and heavily use benchmark allocations. Over the investing horizon, they maintain their investment level. PMS, on the other hand, gives its investors greater leeway.

    This resource equips portfolio managers with the means to manage funds and more visibly display their ideas in the portfolios they construct. Thus, private market securities (PMS) may provide greater returns than mutual fund schemes.Accounts

Mutual funds store their stocks and cash in a single, centralized account, but clients of a Portfolio Management Service each have their own Demat account and bank account.

  • Value

The NAV, or Net Asset Value, of an investor's fund units, determines the value of their stake in a mutual fund scheme. Yet, PMS considers both the value of the investor's Demat securities and their cash.

  • Transparency

Investor has full transparency into their trades, brokerage fees, and execution prices using PMS. The costs associated with the portfolio's upkeep will be available to him.

Yet, a mutual fund is less open and provides less information about its expenses. When it comes to mutual funds, NAV and its reporting are everything.


Remember that even if the market gives you MF and PMS as investment vehicles (amongst others), they each come with benefits and drawbacks to consider. Understand your investing objectives, and conduct a risk tolerance assessment.While investing in PMS, a person must choose both a competent fund manager and an appropriate fund. Investors need to examine whether or not the returns offered by PMS investment strategies can compete with those of mutual funds. A PMS may be the best choice for investors with high net worth, while regular investors may choose to put their money in mutual funds.